Wellness
To ice or not to ice? Icing promotes muscle regeneration after mild injury
Cumulative research by a multi-institutional Japanese research collaboration reveals that ‘to ice or not to ice’ may depend on the degree of muscle injury.
Applying ice to a muscle injury is a widespread first-aid treatment, but exactly what effect does this have on the muscle regeneration and does it really help? Cumulative research by a multi-institutional Japanese research collaboration reveals that ‘to ice or not to ice’ may depend on the degree of muscle injury.
In their latest research, the group consisting of Associate Professor ARAKAWA Takamitsu and Master’s student NAGATA Itsuki (from Kobe University’s Graduate School of Health Sciences), and Assistant Professor KAWASHIMA Masato (Kawasaki University of Medical Welfare) et al. have shown that applying ice to muscle damage in a small percentage of muscle fibers in rats promotes muscle regeneration. This is believed to be the first study in the world to show benefits of icing on muscle repair. In conjunction with their previous study on serious muscle injuries (‘Icing muscle injuries may delay recovery’), it is hoped that these results can be used as a basis for more accurate guidelines on whether or not to ice such injuries.
These research findings were first reported in the American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology on March 6, 2023.
Main Points
- The experiments showed that applying ice after a mild muscle injury promotes muscle regeneration.
- This is believed to be the first time in the world that a study has shown a positive effect of icing on muscle regeneration.
- The researchers showed that the extent of the injury may have a greater impact on the effectiveness of icing than the method or timing employed.
- The findings of this ongoing research will lead to the spread of more accurate information on the effects of icing throughout hospitals, and in the realms of sports and physical education.
‘RICE treatment’ is a common approach for treating the acute phase of sports injuries. This acronym stands for Rest, Ice, Compression and Elevation and it is also often used in physical education in schools and even clinical settings. There are a variety of subsequent steps that can be taken to treat the injury afterwards, yet opinions vary as to whether or not icing should be applied. However, there is a lack of evidence on the benefits of icing.
The current research team has conducted many experiments to investigate the effectiveness of icing, which led them to publish their previous findings (‘Icing muscle injuries may delay recovery’ ). However, no previous animal experiments have indicated that icing promotes muscle regeneration.
In this study, the researchers focused on altering the severity of the muscle injury in the experiments. The reasoning behind this was that the majority of sports-related muscle injuries are limited; in other words less than 10% of the overall number of muscle fibers (myofibers) are damaged and necrotized. However, all animal experiments up until now had looked at more serious injuries where over 20% of the myofibers were damaged.
Thus, the team devised an animal model for mild muscle injuries, and experimented with applying ice after injury using a similar method as before.
After the animal was anaesthetized, the muscle was exposed and clamped between forceps to induce injury. In their previous experiments, the researchers attached a 500g weight to the forceps, which induced an injury that affected 20% of the total number of fibers in the muscle. In the present study, they tried attaching a 250g weight to the forceps and demonstrated that this could be used to consistently injure 4% of the fibers (Figure 1). This is similar to the degree of injury that often occurs after sports activities such as vigorous exercise or long-distance marathon running.
Icing was carried out by placing polyethylene bags of ice on surface of the skin over three 30-minute sessions per day, with each session being 1.5 hours apart. This was continued until two days after injury for a total of 9 icing sessions (i.e. immediately after injury = 3 sessions, 1 day after injury = 3 sessions, 2 days after injury = 3 sessions). The icing method was the same as in the previously reported study (‘Icing muscle injuries may delay recovery’).
Observations of muscles that were regenerating in the icing group and no-icing group 2 weeks after injury revealed significant differences in the size of regenerating fibers in cross-sections (Figure 2). In other words, this demonstrated the possibility that skeletal muscle regeneration is promoted by icing.
Macrophages are immune cells that orchestrate the reparative process of injured muscle. Pro-inflammatory macrophages accumulate in the damaged site soon after injury occurs, however they express an inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), which has a disadvantageous side-effect of expanding the injury’s size. The results of this team’s experiments revealed that icing after mild muscle injury reduces the accumulation of iNOS-expressing pro-inflammatory macrophages. By causing this phenomenon, icing prevents the expansion of muscle injury size.
In other words, icing attenuates the recruitment of pro-inflammatory macrophages in the injury site. This was also reported in their previous study (‘Icing muscle injuries may delay recovery’), demonstrating that this is an effect caused by icing regardless of whether the muscle injury is serious or mild. In the previous study, icing was found to delay the regeneration of muscle after a serious injury that destroyed many fibers because the pro-inflammatory macrophages were unable to sufficiently phagocytose (*5) the injured muscle. In contrast to this, the current study shows that icing has a positive effect when the muscle injury is mild because it prevents the secondary expansion of the muscle injury caused by the pro-inflammatory macrophages. It suggests that this particular effect of icing is connected to the promotion of muscle regeneration.
Icing has been used in the treatment of muscle injuries for a long time, however the positive effects of icing had yet to be elucidated until now. This study has shown that icing can promote muscle regeneration when used to treat commonly-occurring mild muscle injuries.
However, this does not mean that icing is effective for all types or degree of muscle injury. The researchers aim to further elucidate and raise awareness of this. For example, the group’s previous study showed that icing actually inhibited regeneration in cases of serious muscle injury. In addition, the term ‘muscle injury’ also includes extremely minute injuries that have yet to be observed through the team’s animal experiments, so it is still unclear as to what effect icing has on the repair from such microtraumas.
The researchers’ next challenge is to determine the extent of muscle injury up to which icing is appropriate. By building upon their previous investigations, they aim to contribute towards guidelines that will enable people in sports and clinical rehabilitation to make accurate judgements about whether or not to ice an injury.
Wellness
Physical activity and appropriate sleep linked to subsequent lower dementia risk
Rgular physical activity, less sedentary time, and appropriate nightly sleep (7–8 h) were associated with a lower subsequent risk of dementia. Regular physical activity was associated with an average 25% lower risk of dementia among the 49 studies analyzed; however, the researchers note that there was considerable heterogeneity between the studies.
Regular physical activity and getting the recommended amount of sleep may reduce dementia risk later in life, according to a study by Akinkunle Oye-Somefun and colleagues, published in the open-access journal PLOS One.
An estimated 55 million people live with dementia worldwide, and both its prevalence and cost are expected to increase, with global costs projected to reach $2 trillion dollars by 2030. Current treatments for preventing or treating dementia have limited efficacy; therefore, public health efforts have also aimed at healthy lifestyle factors to reduce the risk of dementia before symptoms occur. Healthy behaviors such as regular physical activity and good sleep hygiene are known to support cognitive health; however, there remains a need to better understand their relationship to dementia.
In this systematic review and meta-analysis, researchers analyzed data from 69 prospective cohort studies representing millions of community-dwelling adults aged 35+, to see if there was a link between the development of dementia and three lifestyle behaviors: physical activity, sedentary behavior, and sleep duration. Each of the observational studies recorded behaviors of cognitively healthy participants, then followed up at a later timepoint to report subsequent rates of dementia.
Overall, the meta-analysis found that regular physical activity, less sedentary time, and appropriate nightly sleep (7–8 h) were associated with a lower subsequent risk of dementia. Regular physical activity was associated with an average 25% lower risk of dementia among the 49 studies analyzed; however, the researchers note that there was considerable heterogeneity between the studies.
Too little sleep (<7 h) or too much sleep (>8 h) was associated with an 18% and 28% higher subsequent risk of dementia, respectively, compared to optimal nightly sleep of 7-8 hours, though there was again considerable heterogeneity among the 17 studies analyzed. Prolonged sitting (>8 hours per day) was associated with a 27% higher risk of dementia among the 3 relevant studies analyzed.
The study is consistent with and expands on previous research, using a large, diverse population with long follow-up times. While the study design cannot show any causative link between physical activity, sleep and dementia, the findings suggest an association between adherence to recommended physical activity and sleep levels in middle- and older-age adults and lowered dementia risk later in life.
The authors add: “Dementia develops over decades, and our findings suggest that everyday behaviours such as physical activity, time spent sitting, and sleep duration may be linked to dementia risk. Understanding how each of these behaviours relates to risk over time may help researchers identify opportunities to support brain health across the life course.”
“Separately, one aspect I personally found most interesting while conducting the study was the relatively limited evidence base on sedentary behaviour. Despite growing recognition that prolonged sitting is distinct from physical inactivity, we found only a small number of cohort studies examining its relationship with dementia risk. This highlights an important gap for future research.”
Wellness
Exercise to treat depression yields similar results to therapy
Depression is a leading cause of ill health and disability, affecting over 280 million people worldwide. Exercise is low-cost, widely available, and comes with additional health benefits, making it an attractive option for patients and healthcare providers.
Exercise may reduce symptoms of depression to a similar extent as psychological therapy, according to an updated Cochrane review. When compared with antidepressant medication, exercise also showed a similar effect, but the evidence was of low certainty.
Depression is a leading cause of ill health and disability, affecting over 280 million people worldwide. Exercise is low-cost, widely available, and comes with additional health benefits, making it an attractive option for patients and healthcare providers.
The review, conducted by researchers from the University of Lancashire, examined 73 randomized controlled trials including nearly 5,000 adults with depression. The studies compared exercise with no treatment or control interventions, as well as with psychological therapies and antidepressant medications.
The results show that exercising can have a moderate benefit on reducing depressive symptoms, compared with no treatment or a control intervention. When compared with psychological therapy, exercise had a similar effect on depressive symptoms, based on moderate-certainty evidence from ten trials. Comparisons with antidepressant medication also suggested a similar effect, but the evidence is limited and of low certainty. Long-term effects are unclear as few studies followed participants after treatment.
Side effects were rare, including occasional musculoskeletal injuries for those exercising and typical medication-related effects for those taking antidepressants, such as fatigue and gastrointestinal problems.
“Our findings suggest that exercise appears to be a safe and accessible option for helping to manage symptoms of depression,” said Professor Andrew Clegg, lead author of the review. “This suggests that exercise works well for some people, but not for everyone, and finding approaches that individuals are willing and able to maintain is important.”
The review found that light to moderate intensity exercise may be more beneficial than vigorous exercise, and that completing between 13 and 36 exercise sessions was associated with greater improvements in depressive symptoms.
No single type of exercise was clearly superior, although mixed exercise programmes and resistance training appeared more effective than aerobic exercise alone. Some forms of exercise, such as yoga, qigong and stretching, were not included in the analysis and represent areas for future research. Long-term effects are unclear as few studies followed participants after treatment.
This update adds 35 new trials to previous versions published in 2008 and 2013. Despite the additional evidence, the overall conclusions remain largely unchanged. This is because the majority of trials were small, with fewer than 100 participants, making it difficult to draw firm conclusions.
“Although we’ve added more trials in this update, the findings are similar,” said Professor Clegg. “Exercise can help people with depression, but if we want to find which types work best, for who and whether the benefits last over time, we still need larger, high-quality studies. One large, well-conducted trial is much better than numerous poor quality small trials with limited numbers of participants in each.”
Wellness
Aerobic exercise may be most effective for relieving depression/anxiety symptoms
While supervised and group exercise may be best for reducing depression, shorter (up to 8 weeks) lower intensity exercise may be best for relieving anxiety.
Aerobic exercise, such as running, swimming, and dancing, may be most effective for relieving the symptoms of depression and anxiety, finds an overarching (umbrella) review and data synthesis of the available evidence, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine.
While supervised and group exercise may be best for reducing depression, shorter (up to 8 weeks) lower intensity exercise may be best for relieving anxiety.
But all forms of exercise are as good as, or better than, medication and talking therapies, regardless of age or sex, the findings indicate.
Depression and anxiety affect up to 1 in 4 people worldwide, with the highest prevalence among young people and women, note the researchers. And previously published research suggests that exercise compares favourably with psychotherapy and medication for easing the symptoms, they add.
But it’s not clear how well exercise might work at different ages, frequency, and intensities.And previous overarching syntheses have focused only on adults or included participants with potentially influential factors, such as long term conditions.
The researchers therefore set out to comprehensively estimate the impact of exercise on depression and anxiety symptoms across all age ranges, including in those with and without a clinical diagnosis; and to find out whether the type, length, frequency, intensity, and supervision of exercise, and individual or group participation might influence outcomes.
They scoured research databases for pooled data analyses of randomised controlled trials that compared exercise with either another type of activity, or a placebo, or no active intervention, and published in English up to July 2025.
Eligibility criteria included planned, structured, repetitive and purposeful physical activities to improve physical and mental health; and all forms, intensities, frequencies and settings (individual or group) of exercise.
For depression, 57 pooled data analyses, comprising 800 component studies, involving 57,930 participants aged between 10 and 90, were included in the overarching synthesis.
These participants had been diagnosed with clinical depression or were experiencing depressive symptoms, but had no other co-existing conditions. Exercise interventions were categorised as aerobic (19 pooled data analyses); resistance, such as strength training (8); mind–body, such as yoga, tai-chi, and qigong (16); or a mix (39).
For anxiety, 24 pooled data analyses, comprising 258 component studies, involving 19,368 participants, aged between 18 and 67, were included in the overarching synthesis. Exercise interventions were categorised as aerobic (7); resistance (1); mind–body (9); or mixed (13).
Synthesis of the pooled data analyses showed that exercise had a medium sized effect on depression symptoms and a small to medium sized effect on anxiety symptoms, with the most substantial effects found for young adults (18-30) and women who had recently given birth.
All forms of exercise were associated with positive effects, with aerobic, group based and supervised formats the most effective for relieving depression symptoms. Aerobic, resistance, mind–body and a mix of different exercise formats had a medium sized impact on the relief of anxiety symptoms.
The effects were on a par with, or better than, medication or talking therapies.
The researchers acknowledge some limitations to their findings. These include the variable interpretations of exercise intensity and length among the pooled data analyses, and the relative paucity of pooled data analyses on the impact of exercise across the lifespan.
But they nevertheless conclude: “This meta-meta-analysis provides robust evidence that exercise effectively reduced depression and anxiety symptoms across all age groups, comparable with, or exceeding, traditional pharmacological or psychological interventions.
“Group and supervised formats gave the most substantial benefits, underscoring the importance of social factors in mental health interventions. With evidence that different characteristics of exercise appear to impact depression and anxiety at varying magnitudes, tailored exercise programmes must be prescribed.”
They continue: “Given the cost effectiveness, accessibility, and additional physical health benefits of exercise, these results underscore the potential for exercise as a first line intervention, particularly in settings where traditional mental health treatments may be less accessible or acceptable.”
-
Destinations4 weeks agoIn an airy Baguio café via Rebel Bakehouse
-
Nutrition4 weeks agoMicrowave frying can help lower oil content for healthier French fries
-
Destinations2 weeks agoFaith, fanaticism, and everything in between in Manaoag
-
NewsMakers1 week agoFeeling unfulfilled could lead to riskier, heavier alcohol use
-
NewsMakers1 week agoCancer risk is significantly higher for adults who never married, large study finds
-
NewsMakers1 week agoHealthier plant-based diet associated with lower risk of Alzheimer’s, other dementias
-
NewsMakers1 week agoSocial support, sleep, pain management linked to mental health in later life
-
Wellness1 week agoPhysical activity and appropriate sleep linked to subsequent lower dementia risk
